The human version (we wrote this, not the council)
This section explains the background to the Vale of Evesham Control Zone. The policy is carried over from the Stratford-on-Avon Core Strategy with the county council's support, and similar designations exist in neighbouring South Worcestershire and Cotswold district plans, though Wychavon proposes to drop it. The 5% threshold has proved appropriate because small schemes have little effect on lorry movements. Larger increases are only acceptable where benefits, such as gains for the local economy, outweigh the traffic impact.
An unofficial plain English summary. The official wording below is
what counts at examination; check it before you rely on anything here.
The text below is extracted automatically from the official PDF and may
contain artefacts; the PDF is authoritative.
.21
Vale of Evesham Control Zone
Within the Vale of Evesham Control Zone, as shown on the Polices Map, business
related proposals which would result in a 5% or greater increase in Heavy Goods
Vehicles (HGV) traffic will need to demonstrate that:
1. The economic benefits of the development, particularly to the local
community, outweigh the impact of the increase in HGV traffic;
2. The development cannot be accommodated on a site with better access to the
Heavy Goods Vehicles Route Network within Stratford-on-Avon District, as
defined by Warwickshire County Council; and
3. The supply and distribution routes proposed to serve the site are the most
appropriate with regard to impacts on the amenity of local communities.
DS.21 ~ Development Management Considerations
Since sites can be sold on, a condition or legal agreement will be applied to a
planning permission to specify the maximum number of HGV movements that would
be appropriate. This would then apply to subsequent occupiers of the site.
For the purposes of this policy an HGV is classed as a lorry over 7.5 tonnes maximum
gross weight.
Policy Justification
2.13.2 The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) makes it clear that policies
relating to transport have an important role to play in facilitating sustainable
development but also in contributing to wider sustainability and health objectives.
2.13.3 The Vale of Evesham Control Zone policy has been carried over from the
Stratford-on-Avon Core Strategy, and its retention is supported by Warwickshire County
Council. Currently the policy is included in the adopted South Worcestershire
Development Plan (2016) and the Cotswold District Local Plan (2018). Cotswolds
District Council are proposing to retain the designation within their Local Plan review.
However, Wychavon District Council’s position on the designation within the South
Worcestershire Local Plan is to remove it as a policy, as they instead consider that the
issue can be dealt with through amendments to the validation requirements for
planning applications to address HGV impacts in the Vale of Evesham through a
Transport Assessment and Statement. Nevertheless, the Vale of Evesham remains
relevant as a zone in which to control the volume of HGV movements.
2.13.4 The policy seeks to control the extent to which new development or the
expansion of existing businesses generates additional HGV movements in the Vale area.
In general, employment proposals which can demonstrate that only a very modest
increase in HGV movement would be generated will be acceptable where they are
consistent with other policies in the Plan.
2.13.5 The 5% threshold specified in the policy has proven to be appropriate in that it
recognises that small-scale developments do not have a significant impact on lorry
movements. Where a proposal would result in a significant increase in HGV
movements, it will be supported only if it can be demonstrated that the reasons for the
proposal, such as economic benefits to the local economy, outweigh the impact of the
increase in traffic. Increases of more than 5% may be acceptable where proposals are
small-scale and the impact of addit